Have you ever stayed at a hotel that made such an impression, your family still talks about it regularly months after your stay? This year, Baron’s Cove Resort is that place for our family. In fact, the hotel has a coveted spot on our Christmas Tree this year!
We spent 3 nights at Baron’s Cove in Sag Harbor, New York this summer and it was one of the highest highlights of the year.
Researching for a trip can be overwhelming. How do you know which places are really worth it? I’ve visited over 25 cities in the past two years and my blog is all about the best of places we’ve stayed, what we ate, and what we did that is worth your time and money.
In today’s post, I’ll be showcasing Baron’s Cove, a harbor-side resort in the heart of the Hamptons and why it is the perfect place to stay in Sag Harbor. Let’s dive right in!
The Town
First of all, one of the best things about the Sag Harbor area is that it’s very centrally located to all of the popular towns in the Hamptons.
We rented a car, and from there, we were able to drive conveniently to Southampton and even Montauk, which is at the very eastern tip of the Hamptons. Bus and train are also popular ways to get there, especially since traffic getting out of the city can be pretty jammed up, but having a car definitely made it convenient to get everywhere we wanted to go.
The Historic village of Sag Harbor is also especially charming and has a myriad of restaurants and shops on its main street. It has everything that makes a vacation fun, including a coffee and donut shop, a fun dockside seafood shack, an ice cream shop, and a lot more. You can find an entire post of all the things we did during our 3 days in the Hamptons here.
The Property
Baron’s Cove is described on their website as:
“The Hamptons’ preeminent All-American resort destination. With sixty-seven charming village and harbor-facing guestrooms, gorgeous lofted suites boasting sweeping harbor views, village rooms featuring intimate private gardens, and cozy dog-friendly accommodations, Baron’s Cove caters to every discerning traveler seeking a relaxing getaway on the East End.”
Driving up is where BC starts to live up to that description. The cedar shake exterior, porch, and rocking chairs do their website photos overwhelming justice with it’s charm and welcoming feel. In those first moments, I could feel my idealistic Coastal Grandmother. Dreams come true.
Walking through the doors to the front desk feels like you’re stepping into a Hallmark movie of some kind. It definitely looks historic but with a modern feel as well.
Dark, rich woods throughout the lobby extends into the small but very inviting bar and seating area. Several tables welcome guests to happy hour. Walking out from the bar area leads directly to the side porch which is decked out with more chairs with the fireplace as the focal point.
The decor is so quintessential coastal, and I want it all for my house. Every space flows so well into the next with the side porch then becoming the outside dining area for The Restaurant at Baron’s Cove, a fine dining experience featuring locally sourced vegetables, fish, and meats as well as an award-winning wine list.
Adjacent to the porch and outdoor dining area is the saltwater pool which is enclosed by a beautifully manicured hedge. The iconic striped awning above the porch brings the entire area together.
The pool is a nice size where there is enough space for kids to play and for adults to find a space to sit without getting too splashed. Sunscreen and water are provided, and there is a pool attendant as well.
On the grassy area adjacent to the pool, they have cornhole set up and right next to that is a small fitness center where you can grab a workout or take a yoga class. There is also a tennis court available and included in your stay plus complimentary bicycles! The Sag Harbor City Center is just a short drive, walk, or bike ride to the resort.
The Rooms
Baron’s Cove offers both rooms and suites (some with private balconies and a harbor view), options include 1 King, 2 queens, or 2 double beds. We had a 2 double bed harbor-facing room located on the first floor. There is plenty of free parking onsite and we were able to park right outside our guest room, so convenient!
Walking in, directly to the left is the bathroom which looked recently renovated. The tub and shower are decorated with subway tile and the sink is a beautiful marble with charming fixtures.
The focal point of the room is the adorable bedding with the vintage nautical BC logo embroidered on the shams. They looked straight out of a Pottery Barn catalog. The sliding glass door opens up to a small sitting patio and the pool from the other side, super easy access!
The overall space is big enough to have a large dresser and big screen TV as well as a wet bar – plenty of space to move around. Overall, I would say the rooms are on the simpler side, but very charming and comfortable.
The Service and Overall Experience
This is always where a resort can set itself apart. Aside from the look and amenities, how does being there make me feel?
One thing we noticed is all the folks we encountered working at Baron’s Cove seemed so genuinely happy to be there. The folks at the front desk were so helpful and made us feel so welcome. They took time to help us get oriented to the area as well as making us aware of and setting us up for our complimentary kayak excursion in the morning.
Once, we spontaneously ran into the chef while we were leaving our room and we started chatting. He enthusiastically showed us some of the vegetables and herbs growing on the property for the kitchen. The housekeeping crew was as cheerful as could be and our bartender just went above and beyond to make our time there so special and personalized. We were made to feel at home and cared for, and that makes all the difference.
Conclusion about Baron’s Cove Resort
Baron’s Cove is absolutely one of the best resorts we’ve ever stayed at. It is truly a perfect hotel all around that the whole family can enjoy and not feel too spread out. The resort is rated as a 3.5 star hotel on Expedia but I am here to adamantly say that the overall experience absolutely feels more like a boutique 4-star luxury hotel.
So, have you stayed at Baron’s Cove? I’d love to hear your thoughts or any questions I can answer. Thanks for reading and definitely let me know if you end up booking a stay!
Leave a Reply